alsorrell It seems like 2.9.5 doesn't honor the Theme settings. In this case, song has no embedded theme. Service has a defined theme. OLP instead uses Default theme.
justme Same. It seems that OLP (2.9.4 and 2.9.5) uses only the Default theme, no matter if there is a specific theme in the song and/or service.
raoul Interesting. I just tried it out, and it works as advertised for me. Does your song itself have a theme set? Make sure the Theme field on the song is empty.